Sharla Ellis holding a red apple and a green apple in front of a Utah home for a blog about comparing mortgage rates and loan options.

SHOPPING MORTGAGE RATES? LET’S COMPARE APPLES TO APPLES

Because the Lowest Rate Doesn’t Always Mean the Best Deal

Rates are on everybody’s mind right now. And understandably so.

When you’re buying a home, your interest rate matters. It affects your monthly payment, your purchasing power and how much interest you may pay over time.

And even with all the attention on rates, people are still buying homes. Life keeps moving. People get married, have babies, relocate, downsize, change jobs, buy their first home or simply find the house that’s right for their next chapter.

So if you’re thinking about buying—or already shopping for a mortgage—you’re probably watching rates pretty closely.

Maybe you’ve checked them online. Maybe you’ve talked with a lender or two. Maybe someone just quoted you a rate that sounds really good.

Shop. Ask questions. Compare.

I think you should.

But there’s something every borrower should understand: The lowest rate doesn’t necessarily mean the best deal.

And before you compare two mortgage quotes, it is prudent to make sure you’re comparing apples to apples. 🍎

Why Isn’t There Just One Mortgage Rate?

One of the biggest misconceptions about mortgages is that there is one interest rate available each day.

There isn’t.

The rate available to a particular borrower can be affected by many things, including credit score, down payment, loan amount, loan program, property type, occupancy, lock period and other characteristics of the transaction.

And then there’s pricing.

The same loan may have different rate options depending on whether you’re paying “discount points” to obtain a lower rate (this is often called a “rate buydown”) or receiving a lender credit (“negative points” where the lender can cover some closing costs) in exchange for a higher rate.

That means seeing a rate advertised online—or hearing that your friend just received a particular rate—doesn’t necessarily tell you what your rate will be.

Your mortgage has to be priced for you and your transaction.

A Great Rate Can Come With a Price Tag

Suppose one lender quotes a lower rate than another.

Is it a better deal?

Maybe.

But before you know that, there’s another question you need to ask: What does it cost to get that rate?

A borrower may be able to pay discount points upfront to obtain a lower interest rate. That can make great financial sense in some situations. In others, paying thousands of dollars upfront to save a relatively small amount each month may not make sense at all.

That’s why I don’t want you comparing just the interest-rate number.

  • Look at the rate.
  • Look at the points.
  • Look at lender fees.
  • Look at credits.
  • Look at the estimated cash needed to close.
  • And look at the payment.

Then we can actually compare.

Wait—What Exactly Is a Buydown?

I get this question all the time.

Simply put, a buydown is a way to reduce the interest rate—or, in some cases, temporarily reduce the payment—by using money upfront.

But there are two very different kinds, and understanding the difference matters.

With a permanent buydown, discount points are paid upfront to obtain a lower interest rate for the life of the loan. That may save money over time, but we need to know how much the lower rate costs and how long it will take for the monthly savings to make up for that upfront expense.

That’s the break-even point—and it’s an important part of deciding whether paying points makes sense for you.

A temporary buydown works differently.

Funds are set aside upfront to temporarily reduce the borrower’s payment during the first one, two or sometimes three years, depending on the program and structure. The actual note rate doesn’t change—the buydown funds subsidize a portion of those early payments.

Temporary buydowns are also subject to loan-program requirements, including who may fund them.

And this is exactly why “What rate did you get?” doesn’t tell us enough.

Imagine one lender quotes you 6.25% and another quotes you 6.50%.

The 6.25% sounds like the obvious winner.

But what if it costs $8,000 more to get it?

Now we have something to talk about.

Maybe paying that $8,000 makes sense because you’ll be in the loan long enough to recoup the cost and benefit from the lower payment afterward.

Maybe it doesn’t.

Maybe those dollars would be more valuable somewhere else in the transaction. Or perhaps seller-paid costs are available and using some of those funds toward an allowable temporary or permanent buydown becomes part of the strategy.

There isn’t one right answer. We have to do the math and analyze things.

So don’t just ask:

“What’s the rate?”

Also ask:

“What does it cost to get that rate?”

Are You Really Comparing the Same Loan?

Two quotes can both say 30-year fixed and still not be the same deal.

  • Is one quote based on paying points and the other isn’t?
  • Are the lock periods the same?
  • Are both lenders using the correct property type and occupancy?
  • Are the down payments the same?
  • Are there lender credits included?
  • Were the quotes produced at approximately the same time?

Mortgage markets can move, sometimes even during the same day. So comparing a quote from Tuesday morning with one from Friday afternoon may not tell you very much about which lender actually has better pricing.

Same borrower. Same loan. Same assumptions. Same timeframe.

Now we’re getting closer to apples to apples.

But There’s Something Else I Want You to Compare

This one doesn’t show up in the interest-rate box.

Can the lender perform?

Because the best mortgage isn’t simply the one that looks best on a piece of paper.

Your lender has responsibilities throughout the transaction. Deadlines matter. Communication matters. Details matter. Your rate lock matters. Your financing contingency matters. Your closing date matters.

And when you’re under contract on a home, execution matters.

A terrific quote isn’t much of a bargain if the loan isn’t handled properly or the lender can’t deliver what was promised.

That doesn’t mean you should automatically choose the most expensive lender because you like them, either.

It means you should look at the overall value of what you’re getting.

  • Competitive financing.
  • Clear communication.
  • Experience.
  • Follow-through.
  • And someone you trust to get you to the closing table.

Those things have value, too.

So How Do You Know Which Mortgage Is Better?

Ask questions.

  • Is this rate locked? If it isn’t, ask what needs to happen before it can be locked.
  • Are there points associated with this rate?
  • How long is the lock?
  • What lender fees am I paying?
  • Are there lender credits?
  • What is my estimated payment and cash to close?
  • Is there anything about this quote that could change based on information we don’t have yet?

And perhaps one of the most important questions:

Who is going to be responsible for my loan from here to closing? And after? Will the lender service your loan or could your servicing be transferred?  That is also important to understand.

You aren’t being difficult by asking these questions.

You’re being an informed consumer.

Shopping Rates? Send Me What You’re Looking At.

Truly.

If you have a quote, a Loan Estimate or even a screenshot of what you’re considering, send it to me.

You don’t have to commit to anything.

I’m happy to help you understand what you’re looking at—what the rate costs, what the fees mean, whether the assumptions are the same and whether you’re truly comparing apples to apples.

And if somebody else has a genuinely better deal?

I’ll tell you.

Because my goal isn’t to convince you that one particular number is the best. It’s to help you understand the whole picture so you can make a decision you feel good about.

Rate matters. Cost matters. Structure matters. Service matters. And trust matters.

The best mortgage isn’t necessarily the one with the lowest number.

It’s the one that gives you the best overall value—and gets you successfully home. 🏡💚

— SE

Let's Connect

You can count on us to provide great loan options and rates, while offering some of the fastest turn times in the industry. Our goal is to act as trusted advisors, providing highly personalized service, helping our borrowers and sources through every step of the loan process – from application to closing and beyond. We have always believed that each client and each loan are precious, and we are fortunate to have the continued support of many satisfied clients. We will work hard to navigate successfully and efficiently through the current environment, as we help a regulated and complicated process seem just a little easier. We look forward to earning your business and having you as one of our “raving fans”! Let’s connect!

Follow Me on Instagram